Replacement Part for Old Garlic Press?

[dannyzmom]

Which one is the one for the OLD Garlic press?
"Garlic Press Gray Cleaning Tool" - item # 257C $2.25
or
"Garlic Press Cleaning Tool" - item # 257D $2.50

I am going to guess based on the lower price and item # that is lower in the alphabet that the gray one is for the old GP...anyone know for certain?

[bethcooks4u]

The replacements part form (available in the download area on cc) says:

Garlic Press (fits item #2575)(available through 2/28/11)
257C Gray Cleaning Tool $2.25

Garlic Press - NEW (fits item #2576)
257D Gray Cleaning Tool $2.50